Here's a little update on my situation:

I talked to Bob Keyes from Bob's Razors. A big thanks goes out to jhenry for introducing me to his services earlier in this thread. Mr. Keyes was very helpful and I appreciated the fact that he was willing to take the time to talk to me about where I was at in the hobby and what I wanted out of it. He and I decided I would send out all three razors and let him pick one (if any) of them to hone. If none of them can hold an edge he said he would just send them back to me and I could approach this from a different angle, perhaps buying a new razor or one that has been restored.

So I am going to send them off tomorrow and go from there!

A big thanks goes out to everyone who replied!

Wish me luck!